MISCELLANEOUS: ATHENIAN LAW COURTS
 
  Athenian Legal System

1. The Juries

  • only qualifications: 30 yrs of age, male, citizen
  • pay intro. by Pericles, mid 5th century, 2 obols/day (raised by Cleon to 3 in 420s)
  • 3 obols = wage of unskilled worker at end of 5th century
  • doesn’t keep up with inflation
  • by end of 4th century, back to only well-to-do for the most part
  • no judge
  • presiding magistrate to supervise procedure and announce verdict but he doesn’t advise on points of law
  • jury fixes penalty (many set by law, otherwise chooses from options presented by litigants.)
  • jury represents the demos, so its decisions are final
  • varied from 200 to 2500, usually odd #’s to avoid ties
Pros
Cons
makes bribery and intimidation difficult

jurors must retain all points in their heads
no specific qualifications leads to fairer representation
“herd mentality”
use of secret ballot to vote often decides if crime fits scope of law

2. Prosecutors

  • (rarely) assembly or council appoints a public prosecutor, usually volunteer
  • Public cases (demosiai dikai) = offences which harm the fabric of the community as a whole, can be brought by anyone (free adult male, that is).
  • Private cases (idiai dikai) = only the alleged victim can sue
  • Prosecutor summons the opponent
  • takes witnesses with him (kleteres)
  • defendant appears before a magistrate under whose jurisdiction the case falls
  • usually the tribal judges (40, 4 from each tribe)
  • could decide issue themselves is 10 drachmas or less involved
  • other cases passed on to arbitrator (unless a public case, then this step skipped) who judges
  • if appealed, tribal judges bring case to court
  • preliminary hearing (anakrisis): details are obscure
  • date set for trial

3. Evidence

  • each litigant gathers his own evidence
    • from end of 5th century on, state archive of laws in the Metroon
    • BUT, no copies circulated in court which led to selective quotation
    • penalty for quoting non-existent law was death
  • 5th century, witnesses testify in person, in 4th century written testimony read out loud by clerk
    • no cross examination
    • witness statements and other evidence sealed before trial begins

4. Timing

  • swift, cases must be settled in a day
  • only 1 public case per jury per day, but could judge several private suits
  • time kept by the klepsydra (water-clock)
    • speaker must finish by time water is out
    • reading of testimony didn’t come out of speaker’s time
    • different trials allowed different amounts of time
    • didn't have to use up all of his time

Prepared by K. Widgren, from: Demosthenes. Selected Private Speeches. Edited by C. Carey and R.A. Reid. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1985.

 
 

Top · Home · Study Tools · Archaeology · Links · Classics Main Page

Last Updated Sept. 2003. Please report any problems with this website to nnorman@uga.edu